Open Thread Wednesday

What’s on your mind? Comment away!

Share this Story:

Connect with BHB

Subscribe to our e-mail newsletter to receive updates.

  • Andrew Porter
  • Andrew Porter

    Became Fish’s Eddy, then Housing Works, then…

    Had container of pickles on each table…

    As I complain, every year I seem to get a year older.

  • Andrew Porter
  • Andrew Porter

    Dining options in 1977, as written up in Brooklyn Law School bulletin (edited, cropped screenshot):
    https://uploads.disquscdn.com/images/cbfea8268794f394c0121e3ef4f3064832eea2d6daac3b162045e037cd8b64c3.png

  • Andrew Porter
  • Banet

    Before Fish’s Eddy wasn’t it a magazine store for a brief moment and before that the Montague Street Saloon for a good while?

  • Karl Junkersfeld

    Mr. Manzini,
    You make many goods points. Nice post.

  • https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x7nPOzGeyaw Arch Stanton

    No great loss IMHO, that place was a zoo and only showed mainstream, usually crap, films.
    I had to leave the screening of ‘Gladiator’, due to the cacophonous din form the “audience”. They gave ma a voucher but gave me a hard time when I went to redeem it a few years later, I wound up having to pay the difference of the ticket price (talk about petty). The film was ‘There Will be Blood’ That was the last time I was there.

  • RickP

    Not just pickled cucumbers, but also pickled tomatoes in that urn.

  • RickP

    Thank you Andrew for this additional history and that menu! I attended Brooklyn Poly. A quick lunch was Michaelangelo’s on Jay Street. A “nice lunch” was walking over to the Piccadeli.

    Poly didn’t have dormitories, but it did have a handful of resident students. They were housed in the Bossert and, later, at the Pierrepont Hotel. It was pretty rundown, in retrospect, but not what it became. The bar off Love Lane was still there — we heard that Norman Mailer drank there. Never saw him, though.

  • kizz

    I spoke to the owner of Clover Hill at 20 Columbia Place. He was inside the restaurant this evening. They are still alive and planning to open next month, if all goes as planned.

    Also, Felice at 84 Montague Street (the southwest corner of Hicks and Montague) had a rather packed house of what seemed to be friends and family for a “soft opening.” They plan to open after this holiday weekend.

  • Jorale-man

    Very much miss Heights Cinema. It wasn’t luxurious or state of the art but they showed films that actual adults would watch, not the mainstream Hollywood garbage that has dominated at Regal/Court.

    You could walk there on a Saturday afternoon, grab a popcorn and be transported to Italy or Poland or France for 2 hours. OTOH, it never would have survived Covid, so its days were numbered any way you look at it.

  • Jorale-man

    Re Felice, I noticed that too. Hope the people in there were all tested and boosted. Would be a shame to have an outbreak for their opening weekend. The outdoor igloos didn’t look so bad, incidentally.

  • A neighbor

    Anyone know what all the fire trucks around Hicks and Remsen were responding to tonight?

  • AEB

    Thanks, Karl. I miss your wonderful vids. Will you oblige and post them again? Please?

  • https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x7nPOzGeyaw Arch Stanton

    I think Nomcebo is usually a female name.

  • https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x7nPOzGeyaw Arch Stanton

    Yes, the former Piccadeli space was occupied by the Montague Street Saloon for a little over 20 years. Then the magazine store, Fishes Eddy, Housing Works…

  • Banet

    Montague Street Saloon had the BEST hamburgers. On a toasted English muffin. Perfect.

    And their fisherman’s stew was hearty and delicious.

  • https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x7nPOzGeyaw Arch Stanton

    It’s a shame it had to close, a real loss for the neighborhood.

  • Andrew Porter

    Nomcebo Manzini was the name of a UN official active in women’s rights—who died a few years ago. For some reason, I do not believe this is the same person. Google them.

  • Karl Junkersfeld

    Absolutely correct. My bad.

  • Karl Junkersfeld

    I’m homebound these days and wouldn’t remember how to edit raw footage if my life depended on it. hehe

  • JT
  • Banet

    The menu has what I’d call “Manhattan Prices”. Not sure if most the neighborhood will go for it. $23 for a hamburger?

  • AEB

    Sorry to hear!

  • lois

    There were a bunch of Poly students living on the top floor of a brownstone on Columbia Hts in the 1960s until 1970, when they graduated,

  • RickP

    I also graduated in 70, somehow unaware of the Columbia Heights contingent. That year, Poly housing was the Pierrepont.

  • Ileane Spinner

    Where did you get this article?

  • Ileane Spinner

    Where did you find this article? As you can see, I’m the author.

  • Andrew Porter

    A Google search, clicked on “images,” and there it was. Cropped from full page, heightened contrast and sharpness.