Law & Order: Cyclists Ignore Ban On Bikes Along Promenade

Brooklyn Heights residents are roiled over bicyclists wheeling down the pedestrian-packed Promenade—which is forbidden, according to the long list of no-no’s along the picturesque walkway. The Brooklyn Paper claims that the rule-breaking cyclists frequently “weave around park-goers and ride all over the borough’s most illustrious sidewalk.”

Community Board 2 district manager Rob Perris says he has received calls about cyclists on the Promenade, and is convinced that even more bikers will turn to the walkway in the future: “As bike riding increases in popularity in New York City and there are more places to rent bikes, we are probably going to see more of this.”

Longtime Heights resident Rob Rosenstein noted in the Brooklyn Paper story, “I’m here everyday and they ride by like nobody’s business. There’s no concern for anyone else.” He says he fears accidents are bound to happen as long as cyclists ride on the walkway.

Neighborhood cycling expert Tony Scarselli, owner of Brooklyn Heights Bike Shoppe on Atlantic Avenue, says bikers ride on the Promenade for recreation, not commuting. But it’s not a safe place for two-wheelers, he says, advising that two-wheelers explore the bike-friendly path in Brooklyn Bridge Park instead. “There’s no reason to ride a bike there; it’s like an oversized terrace for the neighborhood.”

Promenade regulars suggest that cyclists may not be intentionally disregarding the rules, because posted signs that also forbid booze, off-leash pets and skateboarding aren’t prominent and could be difficult for them to read. “The signs are so small, you can barely see them,” said resident John McKaig. “Maybe if they were bigger, people would pay attention.”

Share this Story:

, ,

  • She’s Crafty

    Bikes and pedestrians don’t really mix. Pedestrians wander all over, and bikers want to go fast.

  • Joe

    The bikers on the promenade appear to be mostly tourist but some do go pretty fast. Saw a couple going fairly fast on a crowded evening this summer which could have injured someone. Visible signage should reduce the number of tourists biking.

    I do think the trash & dog poop in the neighborhood is becoming a bigger problem. Today I saw not 1 but 2 bags of poop thrown near the tires of parked cars in front of Pierrepont Playground– just steps away from a garbage can.

    Why go through the trouble of cleaning up after your dog only to chuck the poop bags into the street when a public garbage can is just a few feet away? Are people that lazy and inconsiderate? The car owners will not only have a mess on their tires but the neighborhood streets will get an unsightly odiferous stain complete with a split plastic white bag. Lovely.

  • Mr. Crusty

    The problem with bikes on the promenade Jorale-man that it makes pedestrians constantly worry as to what might be coming up behind them. It makes what should be a relaxing stroll into an anxiety producing event much like walking across the Brooklyn Bridge is currently.

  • Robert Perris

    yoohoo, thanks for the shout-out. Community Board 2 has been in contact with the parks department.

  • Wrennie

    @bagelboy, did it ever occur to you that maybe the narrow escalator is for people who aren’t lazy disgusting people who can’t manage to walk up a moving staircase? if you want to be lazy, go on the other one–don’t block everyone else from getting on with their days. For the record, I lug lots of stuff around all the time; even my bike on weekend mornings…I either use the stairs, or I walk up the escalator because it’s faster than walking up the stairs. So don’t get mad at people for being impatient with lazy people who are too inconsiderate to stand on the wider escalator.

  • bagel boy

    wrennie: you are a self absorbed idiot. Did you ever think that some people have disabilities such as heart conditions or bad knees that arent visible that make it uncomfortable or impossible to walk up a moving escalator. Im glad you like to run up the stairs with all your bags in the summer heat .. Bully for you- arent you special, you go girl. You are probably just in a hurry to check your iphone for a message or a phone call that you missed while underground. Honestly, is that 1 or 2 minutes really that important to your precious day.. maybe you get an extra 2 minutes to live in your pretend vapid world of importance .. I hope when you get hurt one day or get old god forbid that some moron causes you to lose your balance and fall over. As long as you land on your head, you will be fine. It is as thick as a brick. Now go play with your iphone and have another meaningless conversation or robot text messaging session.

    Oh and by the way. Did I say you were a self absorbed vapid idiot? Yes, oh yes I did.

  • ColumbiaHeightster

    Re: smoking on the Promenade, cigarettes are not the only problem. Yesterday at around 3:30 I saw three kids lighting up a joint right at the Remsen entrance…it’s not uncommon either. I usually run out there daily around 6am, and you’d be shocked at how many people are inspired to wake up that early to smoke weed.

    Seems like everyone here is passionate about keeping the Promenade bike-free, litter free, and I assume drug-free. So, instead letting a rare thing that we all agree on drift aimlessly into cyberspace, let’s do something about it. What can we do? I’m asking honestly, because I don’t know.

  • Wrennie

    @bagel boy, slow clap for your incoherent babbling about text messages and iphones. very mature of you to wish bodily harm on other people you don’t know.

    the people i referenced ARE lazy. i’m not talking about people who have disabilities (although, again, there’s another escalator.) so grow up and chill out.

  • bored at work

    @James

    Wrong about sidewalk restrictions having no age limit.
    From the nyc.gov website:

    Ride in the street, not on the sidewalks (unless rider is age 12 or younger and the bicycle’s wheels are less than 26 inches in diameter).

    There is no excuse for adults on the sidewalk or on the Promenade.

  • Amanda Tree

    I think the whole “outdoor-regulating” system is impacted by it’s very nature.

    When people are outdoors, they naturally tend to perk up and want to do fun stuff when possible, and probably feel very “rah-rah” about their bikes and (assumed) freedom to ride when possible.

    It’s hard to know why people would even want to ride on the Promenade, but maybe cos it’s so lovely there, people get this charge out of the combination of riding and looking at something so nice.

    This may seem strange, but in all these years I never even knew it was not allowed. It never appealed to me to do only cos it’s too curtailed by pedestrians to really get to ride right, and funnily enough, the only time I did ride was on a shoot done there, and I was asked to ride my bike, very slowly, on camera.

    When film shoots are done, Production aptly keeps the area clear for the scenes, so no civilian pedestrians were there. They had a set group doing an action, and the Principle Players were strolling and conversing as the Background Action was performed, over and over till the scene was covered.

    That was my memory of riding on the Promenade, and it was fine, but very exacting, and not what I would call a recreational ride.

    Now as for the creepy smoking, have to say I’ve always dreaded it taking place anywhere, sorry smokers, it’s not you, just the awful stuff that comes out in the flumes of gaggy smoke, just when you’re trailing along thinking “what a lovely day, how nice to be outside in the fresh….ooops, a flume of smoke up ahead now, let’s bound off to another side, or scoot like Road Runner up ahead so avert the gaggy stuff impeding the reverie!”

    Hearing that smoke became “illegal” in parks and such, I was momentarily elated, only to realize it was a utopian, idealistic wish, a thought-wave that had a brief breath of hope, but no realistic enforcement or even acknowledgement; met by raised eyebrows, disgruntlement and indignation by smokers, smiled at wryly by others, and totally placed in an idea-file, it seems.

    Well, anyhow, that’s just my view of it for now.

  • raj

    There is nothing more than can be done than better signage. Oh and telling people to get off the bikes. But I must say if you think this is bad, wait until the bike-share program.

  • Hicks St Guy

    @Raj, just came back from Barcelona, wish you could have seen their bike-share program, as you would definitely change your mind. why are people so afraid of change?

  • Willowtowncop

    It’s actually written into the anti smoking law that it can’t be enforced by anyone other than Parks Enforcement. The NYPD couldn’t write those tickets if they wanted to.

  • Wiley E.

    Let’s just shoot them. Hehh…

  • AnonyMom

    Anecdotally, most of the bike riders I see are on rented bikes and are (mostly) tourists.

  • http://n8han.technically.us/ Nathan H.

    In most of the civilized world you can ride a bicycle anywhere in a city park, typically to wherever you are going to hang out and relax. You’ll see everyone from grannies to toddlers amble along through a park path, and nobody is getting run over or throwing a fit.

    So these same human beings visit New York to spend loads of money, and maybe rent a bicycle for a day. At that point they become “bike people” in the eyes of many New Yorkers, who basically deserve to die. On the streets they’ll be subject to the whims of generally unpoliced motorists, who use their lethal mass to intimidate and punish anyone who gets in the way—enduring this has a certain third-world charm, but you could also end up dead (as many do).

    So after cheating death on the mean streets, many tourists will take refuge in the first park they see. Entering the Promenade, perhaps they don’t see the signs about all the special New York-y rules because they are busy taking in one of the most famous skylines on earth. Or maybe they do see the signs, but figure that like most rules in this city, those are ignored by everyone. (Have you seen the signs about no honking? What a laugh!)

    So they ride through the Promenade, as despicable bike people who have no morals. They flout the rules, knowing that it will cause helpless New Yorkers to have a stroke at the mere sight of a bicycle being ridden in some space that is not horrible and deadly (the street). Someone could get hurt! It’s very important to maintain the existing order of pedestrians and cyclists being killed in the streets every day, and eternally at odds in parks.

    Also a special note for James who says, “By the way – children must obey these laws also since there are no age restrictions.” That is not actually true, there is exactly such an exception:

    “Ride in the street, not on the sidewalks (unless rider is age 12 or younger and the bicycle’s wheels are less than 26 inches in diameter).”
    http://www.nyc.gov/html/dot/html/bicyclists/biketips.shtml

  • David on Middagh

    Nathan, excellent perspective.

    For all the reasons mentioned so far, it would be hard to eliminate bikes from the Promenade.

    I’m currently bikeless, but have actually gone home via the Promenade *without dismounting* several times in the past, knowing it was against the rules, and yet not hitting anyone. I try not to, but the Promenade is incredibly pleasurable to bike on when not crowded. And so much less stressful than dodging potholes while competing with cars on Columbia Heights or Hicks.

    There. Now I’ve outed myself as an outlaw biker. I still think that mixing bicyclists with pedestrians is the lesser evil.

  • Andrew Porter

    A lawsuit is being filed on Thursday against the city and its bike practices in Central Park, which to all extent prevents blind and disabled people from accessing that park. I suspect the outcome of that suit will ultimately impact bike riders on the Promenade.

  • Lorinda

    The bike-hire company Blazing Saddles provides customers with a map that actually shows that riding is permitted on the Promenade. This company need to change their maps. Better signs need to be in place and there are plenty of cops in the neighborhood. Can’t at least one of them be on the promenade?