Town Hall Addresses Overcrowding at P.S. 8 in Brooklyn Heights

by Beth Eisgrau-Heller

In case you haven’t heard, PS8 is overcrowded. The Annex, completed in 2011 was supposed to help. Instead it was filled to capacity almost the minute it opened. Add unchecked residential development and BOOM, the student population has exploded once again.

To ameliorate overcrowding PS8 did away with Pre-K for the 2014-15 school year and added a sixth Kindergarten class. But the enrollment numbers are proving to be unsustainable. Now there is a chance Kindergarten classes will be cut back from six to five classes for the 2015-16 school year. If that happens, it is projected five to ten children zoned for PS8 may be offered alternative placement and First through Fifth grade classrooms could ultimately swell to as many as 32 children. The DOE will not make a decision about Kindergarten until sometime in March. There is a lot of uncertainty and anxiety. Parents are heated.

Enter PS8 PTA Co-Presidents Kim Glickman and Ansley Samson. First, they mobilized awareness and created petitions for the Department of Education and our elected officials (sign them HERE.

Last night they held a town meeting at Plymouth Church in order to outline the scope of the problem and galvanize the community. In attendance were scores of concerned parents, Department of Education representatives Estelle Acquah and Thomas Taratko, PS8 Principal Seth Phillips, NYS Senator Daniel Squadron, NYS Assembly Member-Elect Jo Anne Simon and City Councilman Steve Levin and community representatives from the Community Education Council (CEC) members David Goldsmith, Ed Brown, Amy Shire and Ed Hagin and Brooklyn Heights Association Executive Director, Judy Stanton.

Ansley, PS8 CO President

According to statistics compiled by Downtown Brooklyn School Solutions approximately 3,750 new housing units have been/will be developed between 2004-2017. Using the School Construction Authority’s “projected public school ratios” this translates into 1088 seats needed at PS8 between 2004-2017. However, these numbers EXCLUDE the proposed Pier 6 tower and Brooklyn Public Library projects. So the problem is likely much worse.

Parents were eager for the DOE and elected officials to weigh in. Thomas Taratko of the DOE offered “You have our ear already, now we are going to take all this back. There are citywide priorities. There are difficult decisions to be made. What I will assure you is that the process will be transparent.”

Throughout the presentation Kim and Ansley emphasized the importance of finding short and long-term solutions but also of working with surrounding communities to benefit the entire 13th District, not just PS8. This sentiment was shared by CEC President, David Goldsmith, “what I’m going to encourage everybody to do…is to look into other options…. We’ll do our best in the CEC encourage the bridge-building.”

Parents were not clear on what their other options would be and became frustrated. Daniel Squadron challenged Thomas Taratko to schedule a forum on Kindergarten enrollment and the promise of an early January meeting was made.

Estelle Acquah, DOE
Photo: Beth Eisgrau Heller

Once the floor was open for questions a concerned Mom immediately asked, “Is there any talk about re-shaping the zones?” Estelle Acquah of the DOE replied, “Nothing is off the table. We will be looking at that. In terms of that being implemented for 2015 just due to the admissions processes and the timelines for those that’s not feasible for 2015. But it is certainly on the table as a long-term option.”

A long-term Brooklyn Heights resident felt, “end of story” that the Brooklyn Heights Library should not be a high-rise but a public school. An opinion shared by outspoken resident Doug Biviano. “We need a moratorium on [the Library] until we solve the problem.”

PS8 Co-President, Kim Glickman is hopeful last night’s meeting will be a catalyst for change. “I was thrilled with the turnout of the meeting. It really showed our elected officials and the DOE that our community is highly concerned with the over capacity at our school. I hope this provides the momentum and the information that people need to find the right solutions for the fall and for long–term.”

So what can you do?

1) Sign the petitions

2) Contact Your Representatives:
Comptroller Scott Stringer: Josh Levin, Community Liaison
Council Member, 33 Council District Stephen Levin:
State Senator, Daniel Squadron: Zeeshan Ott, Deputy Chief of Staff
State Assemblywoman-elect, Jo Ann Simon:
Brooklyn Borough President, Eric Adams,
NYC Department of Education:

3) Attend upcoming meetings. Check PS8 website for updates.

Share this Story:

  • Poplar

    Thanks for this report Beth!

  • Mary

    Great reporting Beth. Thanks especially for spelling out what we can do to push for action.

  • jc

    the park can build a school at pier 6 instead of a condo since they don’t need the money anymore. it’s the only responsible thing to do given that they developed so much of the park creating an influx of kids into the neighborhood. battery park city set the precedent with the same park model–they built 3 schools within the park. we can build at least one.

  • Martin Hale

    The 2005 EIS prepared by Brooklyn Bridge Park showed school capacity at 60%. It is now 140% *without* the new developments at Pier 6 and the Library. Yet the Park’s environmental “analysis” released last Friday insists there have been no major changes warranting a supplemental EIS. They use today’s overcrowding as a baseline rather than the 2005 EIS. Parents and citizens ought to be outraged at this arbitrary, capricious, and cynical interpretation by the Park. If you care about these matters, encourage the BHA to take a stronger stand and contact the Mayor via this form

  • Beth Eisgrau-Heller

    For those that missed the meeting, here is a link to PDF version of the presentation.

  • nicky

    pier 6 is not a central location for a school The library site is more centrally located and can serve students from the new downtown building boom

  • nicky

    the only politican who had something to say was Daniel Squadron who said they had the same problem in Manhattan and built a school.-easy solution