Does Brooklyn Heights Have a Record for Sidewalk Shed Duration?

If you count the time a sidewalk shed has been in place at a particular location, not considering that the shed at that location has been replaced several times, I think St. Ann & the Holy Trinity Church, at Montague and Clinton (photo) may hold the record hands down. I could swear that when I moved to the Heights in July of 1983 there were sheds along the full extent of the Clinon and Montague sides. The shed along the Montague side, except for a small portion over the Court Street subway station entrance which remains today but is obscured by trees in the photo, came down after most of the church’s facade on that side had been repaired and stabilized.

That work, which was done under the supervision of experienced stone workers by students learning the trade, was funded by “Arts at St. Ann’s,” a series of concerts, plays, poetry readings and the like which, from 1980 to 2006, raised approximately $4 million for restoration of the facade and stained glass windows. A previous Rector of St. Ann’s decided that the arts program had become a distraction from the church’s primary mission, so gave notice it could no longer use the church’s premises. Arts at St. Ann’s then decamped for DUMBO and became St. Ann’s Warehouse.

I was hoping that the designation of St. Ann’s as a Pro-Cathedral of the Episcopal Diocese of Long Island might bring some funding for facade restoration, but so far no luck. Hence, the sidewalk sheds remain under a city statute that requires them to be in place next to any building exterior wall not deemed safe from ejecting potentially injurious or deadly chunks of stone or terra cotta.

So, there it is, but I sense some of you shouting, “What are these ‘sidewalk sheds’? Don’t you mean ‘scaffolding’?” Well, no. As this Untapped Cities article points out, the temporary structures that jut out over sidewalks to protect pedestrians from falling debris are properly called “sidewalk sheds” (I’ve also seen them called “sidewalk bridges”). “Scaffolding” is a structure that sometimes, though not always, rises above a sidewalk shed. It supports workers as they work on the walls of buildings.

Share this Story:

,

  • Peter Scott-Thomas

    It's tough enough to get things done in NYC, but when religious institutions "behave badly" – certainly violating anything like "being a good neighbor," I think we have one of those vestiges of a time when religion was central to our society limping on to almost everybody's disadvantage.

    Yes, there are still many observant Jews & Catholics in NYC, and politicians are particularly loathe to rub local priests & rabbis & ministers the wrong way. Plus, those institutions (if you only knew how much of Manhattan is STILL owned by the Episcopal Church!) are not without financial clout.

    Ostensibly, we've separated church from state, but there are numerous examples of a double standard at work. That it's cheaper to leave a shed up for decades than to remediate whatever resulted in the shed being there is intolerable. There are bus lines in Manhattan where you buy a "ticket" before you board. If you skip that step and get caught, you don't pay a $3 fine or penalty. It's somewhere between $50 and $100.

    Nobody on the City Council is so stupid that they can't grasp the realities here. They're just too craven to act, because a vocal minority is pulling their strings.

    Of course, bigger issues feature the same dynamic. We very much need a tax (financial disincentive that NYC administers) on long vacant commercial space. We need to SEIZE buildings like the one on Columbia Heights. Both call for City Council-people with a spine! There's allegedly no City money to help poor people NOT die from heat-related causes. All 3 of the above would improve life for 99.9% of New Yorkers … AND raise $Billions over time!

  • nystrele

    I would opt for 62 Montague Street. I lived there for 13 years and I swear the damn shed was up more often than not.

  • https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x7nPOzGeyaw Arch Stanton

    I agree, the St Ann's Shed holds the "presence" record, albeit not continuously.
    Part of the problem is the uncertainty in how to determine if a structure, especially one like a Church Steeple, is safe? The building is over a 170 years old. Built at a time when there were no uniform building codes, constructed out of materials like natural Brownstone that decay over time and can spall off pieces unpredictably. Now put yourself in the shoes of the engineer who inspects it. How can you be absolutely sure the structure is safe, are you going to stake someones life and or your career on it?

  • Andrew Porter

    There used to be a sign saying who funded the work, with Gov. Pataki's name on it, as well as Commissioner whose family runs a furniture store chain.

  • http://selfabsorbedboomer.blogspot.com/ Claude Scales

    I remember that. I think the Pataki sign lasted through much of the Cuomo governorship.